# Reopening a Fiscal Criminal or Criminal Case in Warsaw — When a Finally Concluded Case Can Be Opened Again

- Source: https://prawoiadministracja.pl/en/aktualnosci/wznowienie-sprawy-karno-skarbowej-warszawa
- Updated: 2026-11-20
- Author: Bartosz Krajewski, attorney-at-law (radca prawny), Warsaw Bar Association of Attorneys-at-Law (https://prawoiadministracja.pl/en/bartosz-krajewski-radca-prawny)

> A final judgment in a fiscal criminal case is not always the end. Find out when a court can reopen the proceedings, what the deadlines are, and why the motion must be signed by a radca prawny (legal counsel) or advocate.

A final judgment in a **fiscal criminal** or business crime case seems like the end of the road — but it is not. Polish procedure provides extraordinary remedies that make it possible to **reopen finally concluded proceedings**, and in cases ended with a penal order a well-used objection is often all it takes. We explain when this is possible and how the procedure works in Warsaw.

## What reopening of proceedings is

Reopening is an extraordinary remedy governed by the Code of Criminal Procedure (art. 540 et seq. k.p.k.), applied also in **fiscal criminal** cases (the Fiscal Penal Code — Kodeks karny skarbowy, KKS — refers back to criminal procedure). It is not a "third instance": the court does not assess the case all over again, but examines whether one of the statutory grounds for opening a concluded case has arisen.

## Grounds for reopening — when the court will open the case

- **new facts or evidence** (propter nova) — previously unknown to the court, indicating that the convicted person is innocent, was convicted of an offence they did not commit, or that the penalty is grossly disproportionate;

- **a crime connected with the proceedings** (propter falsa) — e.g. false testimony, forged accounting documents or bribery, if it could have affected the content of the ruling;

- **a ruling of the Constitutional Tribunal** — where the provision on which the judgment was based has been declared unconstitutional;

- **a decision of an international body** (e.g. the ECtHR), where the need to reopen follows from that decision;

- certain **absolute grounds of appeal** — e.g. the case was decided by a judge who should have been excluded, or the accused had no defence counsel where representation was mandatory.

## Deadlines and direction of reopening

- **in favour of the convicted person** — the motion is not time-limited; it can be filed even many years after the judgment, and also after the sentence has been served or after the convicted person's death;

- **to their detriment** — possible only exceptionally and within a short statutory window from the moment the ruling became final;

- in cases concluded before a district court the motion is examined by the **regional court**, in cases concluded before a regional court — by the **court of appeal**, and after a judgment of the court of appeal — by the **Supreme Court**.

## Mandatory attorney representation — you cannot file the motion yourself

A motion to reopen proceedings is subject to **mandatory attorney representation**: it must be drafted and signed by a **radca prawny (licensed legal counsel) or advocate**. A motion filed personally by the convicted person has no effect — the court will call for the defect to be cured and, without a lawyer's signature, will leave it unexamined. In practice this is a real advantage: a professional lawyer will first review the case file and tell you honestly whether a ground for reopening exists at all — instead of exposing you to the costs of an attempt doomed from the start.

## Penal order in a fiscal criminal case — faster than reopening

A huge share of KKS cases (e.g. unfiled tax returns, unreliable books, unpaid taxes) end with a **penal order** issued without a hearing and without the accused taking part. Such an order can be challenged by an **objection filed within 7 days** of service — once it is filed, the order loses force and the case goes to an ordinary hearing, where a real defence can be mounted (including negotiating voluntary submission to liability on much better terms). If the objection deadline passed through no fault of your own — for example the order was served at a wrong address — a motion to **restore the deadline** is possible.

## Interlocutory appeals and procedural steps while the case is pending

We also provide ongoing defence in criminal and fiscal criminal cases in Warsaw: **interlocutory appeals** against orders (asset freezes, seizure of items, blocked bank accounts), participation in interrogations, evidentiary motions, and representation before tax offices and customs-fiscal authorities at the pre-trial stage. The earlier a lawyer enters the case, the more can be saved. The deadlines for these remedies are collected in [interlocutory appeal and appeal in a fiscal penal case](https://prawoiadministracja.pl/en/aktualnosci/zazalenie-apelacja-sprawa-karno-skarbowa).

## How we work on a reopening

- **analysis of the case file and judgment** — we assess whether a statutory ground for reopening exists (this is the stage at which we tell you frankly what the chances are);

- **gathering the evidence** — new documents, witnesses, expert opinions, rulings of the Constitutional Tribunal or the ECtHR;

- **drafting and signing the motion** by a legal counsel, plus representation before the court examining the reopening;

- after reopening — **defence in the renewed proceedings**.

Fiscal criminal cases often go hand in hand with parallel tax proceedings — we handle both tracks. See also our [criminal law Warsaw](https://prawoiadministracja.pl/en/uslugi/prawo-karne-warszawa) and [administrative and tax law](https://prawoiadministracja.pl/en/uslugi/prawo-administracyjne-warszawa) services. A consultation starts with a review of the case file — bring the judgment and your documents, and we will tell you straight whether the case is worth fighting.

## Useful links

- [Law firm in Warsaw — when to use a legal counsel and how to choose the right firm](https://prawoiadministracja.pl/en/aktualnosci/kancelaria-prawna-warszawa)
- [National Revenue Administration (gov.pl)](https://www.gov.pl/web/kas)

## Frequently asked questions

### Can I file the motion to reopen proceedings myself?

No. The motion to reopen is subject to mandatory attorney representation — it must be drafted and signed by a radca prawny (legal counsel) or advocate. A motion filed on your own will be left unexamined once the call to cure the defect proves ineffective.

### How much time do I have to reopen a fiscal criminal case?

A motion in favour of the convicted person is not limited by any deadline — it can be filed even years later and after the sentence has been served. Reopening to the detriment is possible only exceptionally, within a short statutory period from the moment the ruling became final.

### I received a penal order in a KKS case — what should I do?

You have 7 days from service to file an objection. Once it is filed, the penal order loses force and the case goes to a hearing, where a full defence can be conducted. If the deadline passed through no fault of your own, you can move to have it restored.

### What can count as "new evidence" justifying reopening?

Anything the court did not know when it ruled: recovered accounting documents, new witnesses, an expert opinion undermining the earlier findings, a final conviction of a witness for false testimony in your case, as well as a Constitutional Tribunal judgment striking down the provision on which the conviction was based.

### Does reopening suspend execution of the sentence?

Not automatically — but the court may suspend execution of the ruling once the motion to reopen has been filed. We usually file such a motion for suspension together with the main application.

## Legal basis

- [Ustawa z dnia 6 czerwca 1997 r. – Kodeks postępowania karnego](https://eli.gov.pl/eli/DU/1997/555/ogl) (Dz.U. 1997 nr 89 poz. 555)

## What the law firm offers in this matter

- Bartosz Krajewski Law Firm (Kancelaria Radców Prawnych Bartosz Krajewski), Warsaw. Cases are handled remotely across Poland, in 8 languages.
- Contact: +48 537 927 737, kancelaria@prawoiadministracja.pl, ul. Marszałkowska 20/22 lok. 72, 00-590 Warszawa
- https://prawoiadministracja.pl/en/uslugi
